How Mexico's health system works

Last Updated: Monday, May 4, 2009 | 8:49 AM ET Comments7Recommend15

By Sheila Whyte, CBC News

Public health-care spending amounts to about $800 per person in Mexico. (Dario Lopez-Mills/Associated Press)

The swine flu outbreak in Mexico is testing the country's complex health system as thousands of worried people pour into hospitals and clinics for diagnosis and care.

The health-care system in Mexico is a patchwork of evolving and sometimes confusing services for 105 million people in a country still suffering from diseases of the developing world, such as tuberculosis and malaria. Meanwhile, first world maladies have also been emerging — the World Health Organization lists diabetes as the leading cause of death in Mexico, followed by heart and liver disease.

As the influenza crisis caused by the H1N1 virus has unfolded, that health system has come under increasing pressure. The ill have been going to local hospitals or clinics, but the idiosyncrasies of the health system mean the facilities they visit can depend on where they live, who they work for and how much money they make.

Mexicans have everything from a small, private system to huge universal health insurance programs that mix private, public and employer funding. Despite the array of services, it's an unequal system, says the Pan American Health Organization, "since the various providers receive different levels of payment and provide different levels of care at various levels of quality."

Public health-care spending in Mexico is rising, but it still has one of the lowest per capita expenditures among OECD countries, with just 6.6 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP). That worked out to about $800 per person in 2006. Canada, in comparison, spent close to $3,700 per person that year and now spends more than $5,000 per person.

Here's roughly how the Mexican private health system is structured:

• About three million wealthy and middle class Mexicans (and foreigners working in Mexico) pay private insurers to gain access to high-quality, state of the art medical services. Many Mexicans who are insured through the public insurance system also pay out of pocket for private care to get better service.
• Mexico's private sector is booming. New clinics and specialized hospitals are growing rapidly in Mexico City, Guadalajara and especially Monterrey. In fact, Monterrey is becoming a big centre for medical tourism, particularly for Americans trying to escape their own expensive health-care system. They're flocking to the city's growing number of gleaming new hospitals for everything from obesity surgery and angioplasty to hip replacements. A hip replacement in the U.S. can cost from $43,000 to $63,000 but in Mexico it's a bargain at around $12,000.

There is also a public system:

• About 50 million salaried Mexicans pay into an insurance scheme, along with their employers and the government, through the Institute of Social Security. The employee pays a progressive amount, according to his or her wage. The institute runs its own primary care units and state hospitals for insured workers, although the quality varies considerably. Critics say some establishments are not properly managed and lack adequate equipment.
• About 17 million state employees have a separate, parallel scheme that they pay into through the Institute of Security and Social Services for State Workers. They also have their own clinics and hospitals.
• The army and navy also have their own separate insurance programs, funded partly through social services, as do employees at Mexico's state-owned petroleum company, Pemex.

Universal health care

Roughly 40 million uninsured Mexicans — the country's poorest — all began moving toward universal access to full health coverage in 2003 through a program called Seguro Popular (Popular Health Insurance). It's the most ambitious health insurance program in Mexico to be launched since the beginning of social security in the country in 1943, and it's meant to reduce the inequality of health services and stop poor families from being financially wiped out by an illness. The federal government has set a target date of 2010 to provide the coverage to all uninsured Mexicans although it's uncertain whether they're on track.

Families pay a premium to join, based on their income, and have to make preventive health-care visits at clinics. About 20 per cent of the poorest families pay nothing.

A recent study published in the British medical journal The Lancet says the insurance program has helped fulfil some of its promise by lowering catastrophic health costs by as much as nine per cent among those who participated. Members also used more in-patient and outpatient services, including checkups for hypertension, a common problem.

The former minister of health, Julio Frenk, said that special programs had helped reduce malaria rates by 60 per cent, TB mortality had fallen by 30 per cent and that Mexico was on track to reduce child mortality by two thirds by 2015.

Mexican children receive the same childhood vaccinations as Canadian children. Dr. Antonio Avina, a Mexican doctor studying in Canada, says that since 2007 there has been an annual flu vaccine for the young and the old, although he adds that it's too soon to say whether it had any protective effect during the swine flu outbreak.

Progress, but problems remain

Avina, who was in Mexico at the start of the outbreak, acknowledges that TB is still "endemic" in Mexico and that the problems of swine flu were not well known in rural areas where there are fewer services for sick people than in urban centres.

'You're working with a country with limited resources …When I saw the Cuernavaca hospital, it looked like 1965.'—Lois Howland, nursing teacher

Lois Howland echoes that sentiment. The nursing teacher from San Diego, who has volunteered at an orphanage near Cuernavaca, says the health system remains fractured and many issues like medical training or followup are not well monitored.

"You're working with a country with limited resources," she says. "When I saw the Cuernavaca hospital, it looked like 1965."

The nurses at the orphanage where she volunteered in Miacatlan couldn't get tuberculin screening materials and they weren't properly trained in how to find TB, she says.

Howland also says there's a "huge disconnect, especially for indigenous people" to get access to decent medical care.

Howland, who once taught nursing at Memorial University in Newfoundland, says that as a result she has a new ambition during her stints at the orphanage. She'll spend less time on the orphans and more time training the nurses.

• Post a comment 7Comments have been posted
• Recommend this story 15People have recommended this story

Story Tools: EMAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK |

Story comments (7)

Sort: Most recent | First to last | AgreedDinorah.as wrote:Posted 2009/05/04
at 8:37 PM ETIt is very good investigation about numbers. I do not exactly all this numbers.
But the sure information I know, I lived in Mexico City for many years, after I lived in Queretaro and Yucatan Peninsula, for nearly 30 years, and my experience is I find the best goverment health ever I see I am talking about public service and I tried too private service of course this is better, even my first pregnancy it was there with the best public service. After all this years I move to London, England UK, there it was my second pregnancy and if this person talk about in Mexico she felt like 1965 hospital I would like she look how looks a hospital in UK, I felt like a second ward time, 1940's it was so dirty, so old, and the service... now I live in Montreal and the health service is the worse I ever see, if you like appoinment will take 3 months maybe if not one year, what about a Pediatrician exist her? they want to see new children? if you go to hospital you can wait one day with a night waiting and in hospital you can see all this people ill in the corredors... this is human? How can somebody can talk about if they do not know arround them!!! Really read this is interesting but will be better if you can talk about REAL health sistem in "First world".... I think somebody have a lot material...

• 3
• 1

3Agree 1DisagreePolicy Report abuseRagin Gaijin wrote:Posted 2009/05/04
at 1:54 PM ETOk Zanney...since you brought it up, why no family doctor? Because there are none taking new patients in your area? From what I know, some of the small towns definitely have problems getting doctors in their communites. I agree something should be done about it.

Ironically, there is no problem gettting Doctors here in Vaughan. In fact my local doctors office has a sign on the door saying they have 2 new doctors, both accepting new patients.

• 1
• 3

1Agree 3DisagreePolicy Report abuseoilisgreat wrote:Posted 2009/05/04
at 1:45 PM ETMy suggestion is for people to quit complaining about health care costs and do something to help reduce them. Practice preventative health care. The easiest thing is to go for a 30-60 minute walk everyday. This helps reduce the prevelance of diabetes, hypertension, high blood pressure, obesity, arthritis, cardiovascular conditions, etc and also helps improve the immune system. Everyone, please start doing this, get your overweight friends, brothers, sisters, spouses and parents off their behinds and start walking immediately. It will do the world alot of good.

• 15
• 2

15Agree 2DisagreePolicy Report abusezanney wrote:Posted 2009/05/04
at 1:11 PM ETOntario takes less care of the poor than Mexico. I have to pay $7.00 to get into my emerg now....and to qualify for drug benefits.....they use theprevious years income, from before i missed so much work, so we can not even pay the deductable......add this to no access to basic services like a physical or a pap smear, or any preventative health care due to the lack of any family Doctors and we would be better off in Mexico.

Ontario is the greediest province i have lived in....fees and charges for almost everything, and if you can't pay, they just charge you more.

I work full time, never been on welfare or EI and think i derserve at least basic medical care. Nope, no Doctor, no care. Must be saving a lot of cash preventing all people like us from getting basic services.

By the way, people have had the swine flu here since February and march, and as a former hog industry worker, i am quite aware that it has been infecting people since 1998 when it started in the mega barns of South Carolina.....their barns were filthy and overcrowded, and staffed with low wage workers from other countries. Their lagoons were scary even from an experienced workers point of view.

We are being fooled into thinking that just because they are now actually tracking this disease, it is new. It is not new, and my family has had this twice. We left the industry beause we were sick all the time. We moved away, but i am now wishing i had not choosen a place in Ontario. I was not aware they did not have medical care that was accessable to the the lower wage earners. If i get asked one more time to follow up with my family DOctor i am going to explode. Who would go to emerg for a pap smear if they had another choice?

• 11
• 13

11Agree 13DisagreePolicy Report abuse