A Rescue in China, Uncensored

Wang Jiaowen/ColorChina Photo, via Associated Press
Rescuers carried an injured quake victim from a collapsed building on Tuesday in Beichuan County, China. The country’s openness about the disaster is a departure from past practices.
Sign In to E-Mail or Save ThisPrintSingle PageReprintsShareDigg
Facebook
Mixx
Yahoo! Buzz
Permalink

ByANDREW JACOBS
Published: May 14, 2008
BEIJING — Mothers wailing over the bodies of their children. Emergency workers scrambling across pancaked buildings. And a grim-faced political leader comforting the stricken and reassuring an anguished nation.
Skip to next paragraphRelated
Quake Toll Rises; China Struggles to Reach Victims (May 14, 2008)
Earthquake in China Highlights the Vulnerability of Schools in Many Countries (May 14, 2008)
Enlarge This Image
CCTV, via Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
Prime Minister Wen Jiabao consoled quake victims in Deyang County. Such images of Mr. Wen have dominated the airwaves.
While such scenes are a staple of catastrophes in much of the world, the rescue effort playing nonstop on Chinese television is remarkable for a country that has a history of concealing the scope of natural calamities and then bungling its response.
Since anearthquake flattened a swath of rural Sichuan Province on Monday, killing nearly 15,000 people, the government in Beijing has mounted an aggressive rescue effort, dispatching tens of thousands of troops and promptly sending Prime MinisterWen Jiabao to the disaster zone, accompanied by reporters.
A hard hat on his head and a bullhorn in hand, he ducked into the wreckage of a hospital where scores of people were buried and shouted: “Hang on a bit longer. The troops are rescuing you.” Throughout the day, the images of Mr. Wen directing disaster relief officials and comforting the injured dominated the airwaves.
With scenes of the calamitouscyclone in Myanmar still fresh — and the military government’s languid, xenophobic response earning it international scorn — China’s Communist Party leaders are keenly aware that their approach to the earthquake will be closely watched at home and abroad. And after two bruising months of criticism from the West over its handling of Tibetan unrest, the government can ill afford another round of criticism as it prepares to host the Olympic Games in August.
In its zigzagging pursuit of a more nimble and effective form of authoritarian rule, China may be having a defining moment. Its harsh crackdown on discontented Tibetans bore the hallmarks of Beijing’s hard-line impulses. But its decision on Tuesday to scale back the elaborate domestic leg of theOlympic torch relay — after a flood of Internet protests calling it insensitive — is a sign that officials are not deaf to public sentiment.
Shi Anbin, a professor of media studies at Tsinghua University in Beijing, said he thought the international uproar after the crackdown in Tibet was having an impact on Communist Party leaders. “My judgment is that the government has drawn some lessons from negative feedback,” he said. “I think it reflects a trend of Chinese openness and reform.”
So far, that approach appears to be paying off. Commentary on Chinese Web sites and in chat rooms has been full of praise for the government’s emergency response. On Tianya, a popular forum where antigovernment postings sometimes find a home, users have been quick to shout down those who criticize Mr. Wen and the military’s delay in reaching some quake victims. “Those who can only do mouth work please shut up at this key moment,” says one posting.
Another writer praised the People’s Liberation Army, saying: “Whenever there’s a life-or-death crisis, they’re the ones on the front line. We certainly can overcome this catastrophe because we have them.”
Chinese Web sites remain heavily censored, and a brief flirtation with openness and responsiveness does not mean that China is headed toward Western-style democracy. On the contrary, if China manages to handle a big natural disaster better than the United States handledHurricane Katrina, the achievement may underscore Beijing’s contention that its largely nonideological brand of authoritarianism can deliver good government as well as fast growth.
Dali Yang, the director of the East Asian Institute in Singapore, said the government might have come to the realization that openness and accountability could bolster its legitimacy and counter growing anger over corruption, rising inflation and the disparity between the urban rich and the rural poor.
“I think their response to this disaster shows they can act, and they can care,” he said. “They seem to be aware that a disaster like this can pull the country together and bring them support.”
The official response since Monday stands in stark contrast not only to neighboring Myanmar’s, but also to China’s abysmal performance during a major quake in 1976, when at least 240,000 people died in the eastern city of Tangshan. The lessons from that disaster have undoubtedly been imprinted on the minds of the men who govern from Beijing. In the days after the quake, the powerful Gang of Four played down the disaster and rebuffed offers of help from the outside world, leaving rescue efforts to poorly equipped soldiers.
Hua Guofeng, who was the chosen successor to Mao and was then out of favor, visited Tangshan a few days after the quake. This act of good will enhanced his power and, along with Mao’s death later that year, emboldened him to arrest the Gang of Four, effectively ending the decade-long Cultural Revolution and ushering in leaders who introduced the economic reforms that continue to transform China.
12
Next Page »
Fan Wenxin contributed reporting from Shanghai.
More Articles in World »
Get Times Reader Free. A Digital Newspaper That Reads Like The Real Thing.
Tips
To find reference information about the words used in this article, double-click on any word, phrase or name. A new window will open with a dictionary definition or encyclopedia entry.
Past Coverage
Disaster Set Off by Colliding Land Masses (May 13, 2008)Powerful Quake Ravages China, Killing Thousands (May 13, 2008)‘No Hope’ for Children Buried in Earthquake (May 13, 2008)World Briefing | Asia: China: 180,000 Displaced After Strong Quake (June 5, 2007)
Related Searches
ChinaAdd Alert
EarthquakesAdd Alert
Politics and GovernmentAdd Alert
News and News MediaAdd Alert

More Articles in World »
',1)">
MOST POPULAR
E-Mailed
Blogged
Searched
David Brooks: The Neural BuddhistsItalian’s Detention Illustrates Dangers Foreign Visitors FaceMaureen Dowd: Raspberry for BarryThomas L. Friedman: The New Cold WarRobert Rauschenberg, American Artist, Dies at 82In Paris, Owning an Eleventh of an ApartmentRough Transition to a New Asthma InhalerKnife Skills: Creating Feasts for the EyesIndians Find U.S. at Fault in Food CostTwo New Ways to Explore the Virtual Universe, in Vivid 3-D
Go to Complete List »
President Apostate?Voter ID Battle Shifts to Proof of CitizenshipClinton Beats Obama Handily in W. VirginiaRobert Rauschenberg, Titan of American Art, Is Dead at 82The Neural BuddhistsThe Oil NonbubbleDrive in Basra by Iraqi Army Makes GainsThe Pundit Analyzing Obama? Some TV Upstart Named RoveDemocrat Wins House Seat in Mississippi900 Trapped After Quake, China State Media Reports
Go to Complete List »
bushchinaobamairaqmodern loveindiamyanmarimmigrationclintonisrael
Go to Complete List »
nytimes.com/travel

Also in Travel:
Advertisements
The blog that covers all things Oscar
All the news that‘s fit to personalize.
In a world of second opinions, get the facts first.

All the news that‘s fit to debate.