YouTube‘s filtering issues still not ‘moot‘

News BlogSubscribe to News Blog
April 18, 2008 4:00 AM PDT
YouTube‘s filtering issues still not ‘moot‘
Posted byGreg Sandoval | 16 comments
A copy of Google CEO Eric Schmidt‘s speech is available at YouTube
(Credit: YouTube)
LAS VEGAS--A year ago Wednesday, Google CEO Eric Schmidt delighted an audience of TV and radio broadcasters when he promised to roll out a system that would mean the end of piracy at YouTube.
"We are in the process of developing tools which are called ‘Claim Your Content,‘" Schmidt said at theNational Association of Broadcasters 2007 conference. "If people tell us this is a licensed copy, our computers will automatically detect that an illegal copy has been uploaded and then automatically delete it."
Schmidt went on to say YouTube was "close to turning this (system) on" and once that happened, copyright violation at the site "becomes a moot issue." But following through on that promise has proven a challenge.
"Key into YouTube‘s search field the names of the last five Academy Award winners in the best picture category and scenes from each will appear. Want to watch the first 10 minutes of the gangster flick, The Departed? They‘re there."
Executives with two entertainment companies that provide YouTube with feedback on its Video Identification system said the company‘s filtering technology has fared well at times but is nowhere near perfect and overall test results are "inconclusive." The sources, who requested anonymity because of the ongoing relationship with YouTube, added that managers at the video-sharing site continue totry and refine the system.
YouTube defended its efforts to protect copyright.
"Since launching in October, our Video Identification system has shown terrific results in its comprehensiveness, accuracy, and scalability," a YouTube spokeswoman said in an e-mail. "Over 100 partners from independent content creators to large media companies are currently using Video ID to easily manage their content. Many have found it to be a helpful tool in generating revenue and exposure for their content in the world‘s largest online video community."
For a long time, numerous copyright owners accused YouTube and Google of profiting from piracy and deliberately dragging their feet in developing a way to cleanse the site. They argued that the availability of professionally created content--uploaded by users--is what draws people to YouTube and without that the site would lose much of its luster. YouTube has always denied the accusations.
Nonetheless, the controversy has damaged some of Google‘s relationships in Hollywood.
Viacom, parent company of MTV and Paramount Pictures,filed a $1 billion lawsuit against Google last year. That case is expected to last years before being resolved and it could help decide what, if anything, a Web site‘s responsibilities are when it comes to policing for copyright violations.
Copyright clips abound
Certainly at this point, it‘s hard to see much change at YouTube since launching Video ID.
Available on the site are literally countless clips from feature films and TV shows produced by small production companies as well as the largest entertainment conglomerates--including Viacom.

Key into YouTube‘s search field the names of the last five Academy Award winners in the best picture category and scenes from each will appear. Want to watch the first 10 minutes of the gangster flick,The Departed? They‘re there. Someone elseposted a series of 12 separate scenes from the film, presumably to get around YouTube‘s 10-minute clip limit.
Fans of Clint Eastwood‘s Million Dollar Baby can watch the "Mo cuishle" episode on YouTube as well as thecoin toss scene from last year‘s best picture winner No Country For Old Men.
Identifying video is not easy, YouTube execs have long said. About 10 hours of video is uploaded to the site every minute. In addition to policing an enormous volume of video, YouTube must first obtain high-quality copies so it can create a digital fingerprint of the film or show. Ideally, the automated system will recognize when someone uploads an unauthorized copy.
While copyright videos are still plentiful on YouTube, there are seemingly fewer complaints from Hollywood. The sources who are part of YouTube‘s testing say the entertainment industry has shown a willingness to give YouTube time to improve filtering.
Some content owners may have also concluded that some degree of piracy is inevitable.
"We still see our content pop up on YouTube," CNN.com Executive Producer Sandy Malcolm told the Associated Press this week. "You deal with it. You try to work with them on rights and things, but I don‘t think you can completely stop it. You just try to beat the tide and try to get your content out as fast as you can."
Google execs continue to say they respect copyright and are working to protect it. Schmidt said protecting copyright was in Google‘s best interest.
"We are critically dependent upon the production of copyright content," Schmidt told the NAB audience a year ago. "Literally, people come to Google to get to somewhere where there is something of value. It‘s very important that we not violate copyright."
 
Topics:
Media
Tags:
YouTube,
Google,
copyright,
filter,
Video ID
Bookmark:
Digg
Del.icio.us
Reddit
Recent posts from News BlogHollywood studios tout entertainment service--for 2009How good (or bad) is Intel‘s graphics tech?Apple stores to get virtual counterparts?Twitter hiccups through a semi-outageBritannica makes content free with widgets, publisher registration
16 comments
Post a comment
TalkBack
It‘s About Exposure
EAddie
Apr 18, 2008, 3:54 PM PDT
How many were not claimed?
AbuLafya
Apr 18, 2008, 10:16 AM PDT
Its the Money
taphilo
Apr 18, 2008, 9:11 AM PDT
Sounds like a waste.
mbenson111
Apr 18, 2008, 7:28 AM PDT
I know about copyright, but...
marrofkane
Apr 18, 2008, 7:03 AM PDT
Rotten, aging, theiving corporations
cybervigilante
Apr 18, 2008, 6:47 AM PDT
CNET has become a mouthpiece for the MPAA?
sismoc
Apr 18, 2008, 5:08 AM PDT
 Read more comments >



About News Blog
Recent posts on technology, trends, and more.
Subscribe to this blog
Click this link to view this blog as XML.
Add this feed to your online news reader
Google
Yahoo
MSN
News Blog topics
AppleBroadbandCar TechCellularCiscoDellDigital KidsEnterprise softwareGadgetsGamingGoogleIBMMediaMicrosoftMusic
Open sourceOraclePCsPoliticsProcessorsScienceSearchSecuritySun MicrosystemsVoIPWeb 2.0WindowsWorkplaceYahoo
Latest blog posts from News.com
Hollywood studios tout entertainment service--for 2009
Posted in News Blog by Jonathan Skillings April 20, 2008 1:33 PM PDT A joint venture featuring heavyweight Hollywood studios is looking to fall 2009 to launch a premium television channel and video-on-demand service that will offer feature films and original television series. The unnamed venture, and the unnamed channel it will produce, has the backing of Viacom and its Paramount Pictures unit; …Read more
How good (or bad) is Intel‘s graphics tech?
Posted in Nanotech: The Circuits Blog by Brooke Crothers fromCNET Blog Network April 20, 2008 12:45 PM PDT We already know that Nvidia doesn‘t think highly of Intel‘s graphics technology. But is it really that bad, or is it good enough for most PC users? Let‘s focus on the graphics technology that Intel has been supplying in volume to notebook PC makers over the last …Read more
Apple stores to get virtual counterparts?
Posted in News Blog by Jonathan Skillings April 20, 2008 10:01 AM PDT A patent filing by Apple is prompting speculation that the Mac and iPod maker could be getting ready to open up Apple stores in the virtual realm--perhaps in Second Life. On Thursday, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office published a patent application from Apple titled "Enhancing online shopping atmosphere," …Read more
Twitter hiccups through a semi-outage
Posted in News Blog by Jonathan Skillings April 20, 2008 8:31 AM PDT The Twitter community may not be paying much heed to your posts this weekend, but it‘s not your fault. The company behind the messaging service and Web 2.0 darling acknowledged late Saturday that some back-end changes had been failing to show tweets from a number of people. A …Read more
Britannica makes content free with widgets, publisher registration
Posted in News Blog by Zoë Slocum April 19, 2008 3:21 PM PDT Before there was Wikipedia, there was Britannica. Really, young whippersnappers, having an organized stack of the neatly bound heavy encyclopedia volumes on library shelves was a status-making must in many U.S. households as recently as the 1990s. With the invention of the CD-ROM came Encarta, owned by Microsoft, which …Read more
Featured blogs
Beyond Binary by Ina Fried A look at how technology is changing our lives and at the people behind all that life-changing stuff.
Coop‘s Corner by Charles Cooper Charles Cooper weighs in on Silicon Valley hijinks, and he doesn‘t suffer fools gladly.
Defense in Depth by Robert Vamosi Covering the latest in computer viruses and computer crime.
Geek Gestalt by Daniel Terdiman At the tech culture nexus of video games, fire art, and virtual worlds.
Green Tech Fresh green tech news and commentary.
One More Thing by Tom Krazit Tom Krazit takes on the tech phenomenon that is Apple, and keeps a close watch on the chip industry.
Outside the Lines by Dan Farber When business and technology meet, that‘s when things get interesting.
The Iconoclast by Declan McCullagh Exploring the intersection of politics and technology.
The Social by Caroline McCarthy Exploring all facets of social media and tech culture.
Underexposed by Stephen Shankland Coverage of digital photography, science, and open-source software.
More CNET blogs »


Welcome (log out) |View profile
|Sign upWhy join?
Remember me |Forgot password?
On BNET:Why back-biting meanies don‘t win
Search: News All CNET The WebAdvancedsearchToday on CNET
Reviews
News
Downloads
Tips & Tricks
CNET TV
Compare Prices
Blogs
Get more done with Windows Mobile
Business Tech
Cutting Edge
Green Tech
Wireless
Security
Media
Markets
Personal Tech
News Blogs
Video
My News
Site map
Help center
Corrections
Newsletters
Send tips
News.com mobile
Content licensing
RSS feeds
RSS
Search: News All CNET The WebAdvancedsearch Popular topics:
CES
Drivers
Games
IE7
iPhone
iPod
iPod Nano
iPod Touch
iTunes
Leopard
Macworld
Nintendo Wii
PS3
Spyware
TVs
Vista
Xbox 360
CNET.com
About CNET
Today on CNET
Reviews
News
Compare prices
Tips & Tricks
Downloads
CNET TV
Popular on CNET Networks:
Akon
Free Music Downloads
Game Cheats
Heroes
Margarita recipes
PC Games
Prison Break
PS3
Recipes
Wii
Xbox 360
Visit other CNET Networks sites: Select Site BNET CHOW CNET.com CNET Channel GameSpot International Media MP3.com mySimon Search.com TechRepublic TV.com ZDNet About CNET Networks
Jobs
Advertise
Partnerships
Site map
Copyright ©2008 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy policy
Terms of use